Dementia Risk Linked to Traumatic Brain Injury History
MAY 15, 2020
Kimberly Peterson, MS
A team, led by Kimberly Peterson, MS, Evidence Synthesis Program (ESP) Coordinating Center, VA Portland Health Care System, reviewed the prevalence of dementia in Veterans compared to civilians and examined the link between previous traumatic brain injuries and the risk and timing of dementia onset in Veterans.
The investigators systematically reviewed various databases from inception until October 2018 on various trials involving dementia and traumatic brain injuries and assessed the articles for inclusion, evaluated study quality, graded strength of evidence, and extracted data.
Overall, they included 40 articles in the final analysis, 10 of which were deemed to present the best evidence.
The investigators found that dementia rates are likely to be similar between Veterans and civilians (10.7% vs. 8.8-11.6%).
Dementia prevalence is also likely to be higher in individuals with a traumatic brain injury (6-16%) than in those without a TBI (3-10%), with a possible dose-response relationship between the 2 groups.
The investigators also found there could be a link between traumatic brain injuries and dementia. However, this evidence has limitations, as no studies have been conducted to evaluate whether dementia prevalence varied on the basis of combat deployment history or era of conflict.
In 2018, investigators found that concussions can increase the likelihood of dementia in patient by two-fold.
Researchers from the University of California San Francisco (UCSF) Weill Institute for Neurosciences and the San Francisco Veterans Affairs Health Care System conducted the analysis on more than 350,000 veterans to find the risk of complications in those who suffered from concussions.
They found that those who had experienced a concussion without loss of consciousness had a 2.36-times greater risk for dementia, after adjustments for age, sex, race, education, and other health conditions.
For those who suffered concussions with loss of consciousness, risk of dementia was 2.51 times greater. Those with moderate-to-severe traumatic brain injury (TBI) had a 3.77-times greater risk.
The analysis was pulled from 2 databases: one with veterans of various generations who had suffered TBIs ranging from concussion to mild TBI in either their military career or civilian life; and another list of veterans who served in Iraq and Afghanistan. The latter list’s veterans were more likely to suffer TBI in combat zones.
The 357,558 study participants (mean age 49) were tracked for an average of 4.2 years.
Researchers defined concussions among Iraq and Afghanistan veterans as mild TBI that resulted in alteration of consciousness and amnesia for up to 1 day, based on medical evaluation. Concussion was defined in other veterans though comprehensive diagnostic codes in electronic health records.
The new data shows that the risk of developing dementia is related to whether or not an individual has developed a traumatic brain injury.
“Dementia prevalence is likely similar in Veteran and civilian populations, and the risk of dementia is likely increased by TBI,” the authors wrote. “To inform development of screening, prevention, and rehabilitation efforts, research is still needed addressing the mechanism of association and timing of dementia onset.”
The study, “Association Between Traumatic Brain Injury and Dementia in Veterans,” was published online in The Journal of Head Trauma Rehabilitation.