Influenza Vaccine Protects High-Risk Individuals from Hospitalizations
OCTOBER 05, 2018
As the influenza virus increases the risk for severe complications and hospitalizations among individuals with cardiopulmonary and other chronic conditions, investigators sought to evaluate influenza vaccine effectiveness (VE) in high-risk groups.
Specifically, VE was assessed against influenza-associated hospitalizations in adults with specific high-risk conditions, such as cardiovascular, metabolic, and lung conditions, in a study presented at the 2018 IDWeek Annual Meeting in San Francisco, CA.
During the 2015-2016 influenza season, adults hospitalized with acute respiratory illness (ARI) were enrolled at 8 hospitals participating in the US Hospitalized Adult Influenza Vaccine Effectiveness Network (HAIVEN) study.
Testing for influenza was performed in respiratory specimens with reverse transcription PCR. Medical records and enrollment interviews also provided data on the measures of illness severity, underlying health status, and vaccination.
Clinical codes assigned to prior year medical encounters determined the presence of high-risk conditions.
A test-negative design as (1-adjusted odds ratio) that compared the odds of PCR-confirmed influenza among vaccinated patients versus unvaccinated controls estimated the VE. Age, sex, and other factors contributed to adjustments in multivariate logistic regression, stratifying by chronic conditions.
“Of 1467 adults hospitalized with ARI, 236 (16%) had PCR-confirmed influenza; 180 (78%) were A(H1N1)pdm09.” Overall, 358 (93%) had ≥1 high-risk medical condition, and 1026 (70%) had ≥3 conditions.
The most common high-risk conditions included cardiovascular (n=835), metabolic (including diabetes) (n=773), and lung conditions (n=692).
Primarily, vaccination was more likely in patients with ≥1 high-risk conditions (70%), while vaccination was not as likely in patients not at high risk (31%, p <.001).
Overall, VE against any influenza-associated hospitalization was observed to be 50% (95% CI: 31-63).
VE was also comparatively high among patients with neurologic (VE=64%, 95% CI: 26-83), cardiovascular (VE=53%, 95% CI: 27-69), and metabolic (VE=55%, 95% CI: 30-71) conditions. However, VE was lower for patients with immunosuppression and malignancy (VE=20%, 95% CI: -42-54).
The study authors concluded that the risk of influenza hospitalization among adults with the most prevalent high-risk cardiovascular, metabolic, and lung conditions is significantly reduced with vaccination. Consequently, the benefit of vaccinating adults with existing specific chronic conditions is only further supported by the study’s findings, which echo previous research indicating flu vaccine effectiveness is influenced by immune history.
In a previous study, co-author by Yonatan Grad, MD, PhD, assistant professor of immunology and infectious diseases at the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health, highlighted a phenomenon called the “original antigenic sin,” which demonstrates previous immune responses are more influential in the VE process.
The original antigenic sin is the result of slight year-to-year virus change that is not caught by antibodies produced by the body during vaccinations. It causes the immune system to inherently reactivate the same successful antibodies every time it encounters the virus.
Additionally, study authors noted that the more history a patient has with the flu, the more likely his or her immune response is less protective to new strains.
To address the sometimes lacking VE in some flu vaccinations, authors concluded more research needs to be conducted in order to investigate the complexities and variations of immune response.
The study, “Effectiveness of influenza vaccine for prevention of influenza-associated hospitalizations among high-risk adults in the U.S., 2015 – 2016,” was presented at IDWeek 2018.
Click here to sign up for more MD Magazine content and updates.
Related Coverage >>>
High-Dose Trivalent Versus Quadrivalent Influenza Vaccination: Which Is Better?
Oral Influenza Tablet Vaccine Protects Against Infection, Induces Unique Immune Response
Flu Vaccinations Can Protect Indirect Contacts
Q&A with Linda Delahanty from Massachusetts General Hospital: Diagnosing and Treating Type 2 Diabetes and Prediabetes